Banting For Weight Loss Diet Analyzed

✓ Fact Checked

Banting For Weight Loss?

With so many weight loss diets available it can be seriously difficult finding one that’s right for you. If you’ve been looking for an effective weight loss plan, you may have stumbled across the Banting Diet – a program that was first developed in 1863!

This diet is a method of slowly and steadily losing weight through a 4-phase program that essentially promotes low carbohydrate intake and high fat intake.

This may well be one of the oldest weight loss plans on record; as we mentioned, it was developed in 1863 by a man named William Banting, a formerly obese undertaker with no nutritional background. Mr. Banting found that losing body fat was considerably easier when high-starch and high-sugar foods were eliminated from the diet – he later went on to write an open letter to the public, disclosing his findings.

In its modern day form it is a members-only (i.e. you need to pay a monthly subscription) diet owned and operated by South African author Tim Noakes. It is branded under the name “The Real Meal Revolution”.

How Does This Diet Work?

To explain precisely how it works we will need to break each phase down individually; the program has four stages that dieters must follow in a step-by-step formula.

Banting Says, Establish Your Awesome Weight!

Before beginning the diet you need to know what you’re Awesome Weight is. This is the weight that you’ll be aiming to achieve while following the diet; the official website has a calculator that you can use.

To “establish one’s Awesome Weight” is just a fancy way of saying “establish your healthy body weight”, i.e. the body weight in which you’d be classed as “normal” on a BMI (body mass index) chart. The idea of chasing an Awesome Weight is to ensure you do not become underweight by sustaining the program below a weight that’s considered healthy.

Phase 1: Observation

This is perhaps the easiest part of the program. Before you make any nutritional or exercise changes, note down your body measurements (weight, waist size etc.) and then spend one week recording data about your lifestyle.

Simply observe and note down everything you eat in a week, to become familiar with your own typical eating patterns and tendencies. The thinking behind the Observation period in the Banting diet is that anything that can be measured can be improved and that it is beneficial for participants to have a good idea of their eating habits before they begin to change them.

The Observation stage lasts for one week no matter your age or weight and it also gives participants a chance to read through the Banting diet material so that they are familiar with the steps ahead.

Phase 2: Restoration

Phase two begins with eliminating the foods from the Red list and the Light Red list in the Real Meal Revolution ‘Real Lists’. After you have removed the foods that are not nutrient-dense, you reintroduce foods known as ‘fertilizers’, which are essentially foods that encourage restoration of your gut lining and the natural gut flora.

The Restoration phase lasts for one week for every 5kg between your current weight and your ‘Awesome’ weight and its purpose is to ‘soften’ the introduction to a low carb diet and minimize any potential negative side effects.

Restoration Phase Daily Meal Plan Example:

  • Breakfast: Bacon, eggs, mushrooms and rocket followed by coconut yogurt and a herbal tea.
  • Snacks: Sparkling water, a banana and a handful of nuts
  • Lunch: Smashed avocado and grilled chicken breast with mixed beans and green salad. A few apricots and a handful of grapes.
  • Snack: Fruit salad of papaya, raspberries and strawberries.
  • Dinner: Chickpea and lentil curry with spicy green beans and garden peas.

Phase 3: Transformation

The Banting principle is not to encourage ‘quick fixes’ and fast one-time weight loss, but to encourage and equip participants to make lasting transformations to improve their overall health.

The Transformation phase is designed to push your metabolism and encourage weight loss by following a good foundation laid out in the Restoration phase. Participants can eat unlimited foods from the Green List and keep to limits on the Orange A list. The Orange B, Red and Light Red lists are to be avoided at this point in the nutrition plan.

Halfway through the Transformation stage (which takes as long as it takes to get to your ‘Awesome weight’) there are some additional factors introduced to speed up results. This phase encourages your body to burn its own fat as fuel and uses cutting-edge research to design the nutritional plan. It has been shown to improve sleep patterns, increase mental clarity and energy levels and even help skin clarity.

Transformation Phase Daily Meal Plan Example:

  • Breakfast: An omelet with spring onions, tomatoes and mushrooms and a flavored water.
  • Snack: Diced mango
  • Lunch: Homemade lentil dhal with sprouted salad
  • Snack: Diced pineapple
  • Dinner: Mexican chicken with tomato salsa and shredded cheddar

Phase 4: Preservation

Preservation is the fourth and last stage, and is designed for people who can make small changes to their diet without it having a lasting negative effect on their health. During this stage you will find out which foods you can eat without gaining weight, and which are more of a problem for you personally.

You will not need to follow the guidelines with regards to the quantity of foods you eat but will need to keep adhering to the ‘top tier’ guidelines with lists of foods to be avoided completely, eaten occasionally or consumed whenever you like.

Preservation Diet Guidelines:

  • Green List: “Eat as much as you like”. The Green List includes foods such as most vegetables, caffeine-free drinks such as herbal teas, coconut oil and seeds.
  • Orange List: “Exercise self-control”. The Orange List includes foods such as nuts, milk and milk substitutes, and most fruits and vegetables not on the Green List.
  • Light Red: “Hardly Ever”. The Light Red list includes foods such as smoothies, popcorn, rice and flour.
  • Red: “Never Ever”. The Red list includes foods such as anything with added sugar plus natural sugars such as coconut sugar and artificial sweeteners as well as gluten.
  • Grey: “Your decision”. The Grey list includes foods such as sugar-free desserts, Banting baked desserts and alcoholic drinks.

Preservation Phase Daily Meal Plan Example:

  • Breakfast: Fruit salad with Greek yogurt and a cup of fruit tea
  • Snack: An apple with almond butter
  • Lunch: Brown rice with marinated tofu and sweet potato
  • Snack: A few squares of dark chocolate and some berries
  • Dinner: Thai prawn curry with coconut milk and a raw green bean and papaya salad.

If you happen to gain weight during the Preservation stage simply switch back to Transformation until you are back at your Awesome weight!

The 10 Golden Rules Of Banting

Along with the color-coded food lists, here are the top 10 Golden Rules that you must follow:

  1. Eat enough vegetables – This is because vegetables are low in calories and high in vitamins, minerals and fibre, meaning that you fill up on good stuff rather than sugar and carbs.
  2. Be aware of carbs disguised as proteins – Legumes, baked beans, peanuts and quinoa are all high in carbs and will slow down fat burning.
  3. Keep snacks to within the foods from your permitted food lists – for ideas check out the online recipe videos.
  4. Eat enough fat – It is a myth that eating fat makes you fat; in fact it helps the body use fat as fuel and ensures satiety after meals, preventing snacking.
  5. Listen to your body – When you are full, stop eating and if you don’t feel like eating, don’t. The aim is to rebalance your appetite and to learn to listen to your body’s own cues.
  6. Don’t eat too much protein – Although the Banting diet is low-carb, it is not high-protein. Following the Banting diet properly should not increase your protein intake massively, if at all.
  7. Avoid overeating fruit and nuts – Fruit contains sugar and although it also has plenty of fibre, sugar is fairly high in calories. In the same way, nuts are nutrient-dense but also high in calories which can prevent weight loss.
  8. Control your dairy intake – Dairy can encourage inflammation and water retention and also contains sugar in the form of lactose.
  9. Keep a PMA (Positive Mental Attitude) – Use the Banting diet’s goal-setting tools to help keep you motivated and on track during your dieting journey.
  10. Learn to read labels – often packaged foods that are marketed as a ‘healthy’ option are full of sugar and artificial sweeteners. If you couldn’t have made it at home yourself, chances are it’s not a great diet food.

Conclusion

The Banting diet is a popular and well-organized diet for people wanting to lose weight with a low-carb, high-fat diet. It offers good value for money and an easy to follow step-by-step plan with plenty of accessible resources, recipes and community support.

Using the Banting program is a good option for people wanting to lose a significant amount of weight in a fairly short amount of time and those looking for a long-term healthy eating plan.

Abbey Carlson, RD
Abbey Carlson, RD
Staff Writer & Fact Checker at DietProbe
Abbey is a registered dietitian who specializes in human nutrition and obesity prevention.
Close Menu

Fact Checked


This article has been reviewed and fact-checked by a certified nutritionist, and only uses information from credible academic sources.